Strange Maps

August 5, 2007

161 - Map of the San Francisco Quake and Fire (1906)

lesliesmap.jpg

On the night of April 17th in 1906, the world-famous tenor Enrico Caruso wowed San Franciscans at the Tivoli Opera House with his performance in Carmen. The next day would – unfortunately – prove much more memorable for San Francisco. That Wednesday morning, at twelve minutes past five, an earthquake with a magnitude of 7,8 on the Richter scale struck the Bay Area.

The quake lasted 42 seconds, causing severe damage. Ruptured gas lines (and the scarcity of water due to ruptures in those lines) caused city-wide fires that eventually were responsible for up to 90% of the total destruction. Additionally, since the insurance companies didn’t refund the actual quake damage, many people set fire to their own homes. The fires raged for four days and nights. By that time, 80% of the city was destroyed. Estimates of the damage range from $500 million to as high as $1 billion (equivalent to as much as $300 billion in 2005 money).

The army was brought in to control the fires (which they did with dynamite and even artillery barrages) and stop the looting. In all, 500 presumed looters were shot. Some destruction and loss of life occurred outside San Francisco, but the bulk of the 3.000 casualties were to be regretted in the Golden Gate city itself. Three quarters of its population of 400.000 were made homeless. Half of those fled across the Bay to Oakland and Berkeley, others took up residence in massive camps of shacks and tents at Golden Gate Park and the Presidio, among other places.

Some of those camps were still open in 1908, indicating the slowness of the rebuilding effort (the city wouldn’t be considered ‘rebuilt’ until the Exposition of 1915). Up until then, San Francisco had been the undisputed economic centre of the West Coast. Los Angeles profited from the diversion of trade, industry and population, and eventually overtook its rival to the north.

This map (found here) was drawn by H.M. Pettit for Leslie’s Weekly, a famous American illustrated news magazine founded in 1852 and operating well into the 20th century, when some of its covers were drawn by Norman Rockwell. As befits a news weekly founded by an engraver, (Frank) Leslie’s Weekly featured a fair share of maps, illuminating a contemporary news story. This map’s title and subtitle are of a charming, old school length and descriptiveness:
Destruction of One of the Greatest Modern Cities. Bird’s-Eye view of Stricken San Francisco, Showing the Burned District, Covering Twenty-Five Square Miles, With the Most Prominent Places and Buildings Carefully Indicated.

Oriented to the southwest, the map surrounds the Burned District with a dotted line, from the Union Iron Works at the left side of the map up to Twin Peaks in the centre of the peninsula, and then along Van Ness Avenue almost to the Bay, taking a right on Greenwich Street via Telegraph Hill to the water, sparing the area around Fisherman’s Wharf. In total, about 500 city blocks were destroyed. Some significant locations are spelled out on the map:

• Examiner Building. Collapsed.
• Call Building. Badly Damaged.
• Valencia Hotel. Collapsed, 17 Killed.
• Mechanics Pavillion. Used As Morgue and Refuge for Injured. Building Burned, Injured Removed, 200 Bodies Left Were Cremated.
• Presidio Reservation. Where 50.000 people Are Encamped.
• South San Francisco. Burning In Spots.

The Wikipedia entry for the Great San Francisco Quake of 1906, on which much of this article was based, mentions Caruso’s traumatic exit from San Francisco: “Clutching an autographed photo of President Theodore Roosevelt, (he) made an effort to get out of the city, first by boat and then by train, and vowed never to return to San Francisco. He kept his word.”

18 Comments »

  1. Also worth noting is the interesting perspective, which makes the “burned district” look like the greater part of the city, when it’s really more like a quarter or a sixth of it.

    Comment by David Moles — August 5, 2007 @

  2. The initial fires were caused by broken gas lines and the severity of the fire was mostly the result of earthquake damage to the water supply. There were reports of people setting fire to their own houses so they could make insurance claims, but this was not the sole cause of the fire, as your text seems to imply.

    Great map and great blog, though. Thank you for your work on this.

    Comment by paul — August 5, 2007 @

  3. David - it may be a quarter or a sixth of the current area of the city, but the majority of the city was destroyed then. I’m not positive, but I think most of the Western and Southern parts of the current city hadn’t been built up yet.

    Nowadays, there are some areas with pre-1906 buildings, but it’s a very small part of the overall city.

    Comment by Robert — August 5, 2007 @

  4. David: That’s the case. Much of the western part of the city was still in parklands. The SW corner (not marked on this map, it’s in the far distance) was nearest the epicenter, but there was little damage there, as there were few people. There were huge refugee camps down there, though, the remains of which were the seeds of the first real housing development there.

    The undeveloped parts of town were mostly sand, marsh and brushy undergrowth, small market gardens where good soil could be found, etc.

    Comment by Mary Mactavish — August 5, 2007 @

  5. Looking at “Golden Gate” at the right=hand edge of the map made me think how different any map of San Francisco would be before the Golden Gate Bridge was built in the 1930’s.

    Also, Strangemaps, I was bothered by your use of the phrase “$400 million dollars’ worth of damage”. It bugs me no end to see the word “dollars” following a “$” and number. The symbol “$” indicates “dollars”, so you’re effectively saying “400 million dollars dollars’ worth”. Please change it to “$400 million of damage” or “400 million dollars worth of damage”.

    Comment by Darrel Jones — August 5, 2007 @

  6. Thanks for digging the map up.

    The dynamiting of the buildings was done to try to stop the spread of the fire but probably did as much damage (if not more) than the fire itself:

    http://scienceblogs.com/nosenada/2006/04/kevin_starrs_take_on_the_polit.php

    The $400M damage number is not reliable (it is one of those persistent estimates that start as speculation but quickly become fact once many people have cited it). The probable damages in SF alone were more toward $524M and some estimates have put total damages near $1B (SF took most of the damage but other cities were also severely damaged, most notably Santa Rosa). A realistic modern correction that accounts for not just inflation but also wealth and population makes the 1906 quake a roughly $300B event in 2005 dollars. I have a paper on this in revision right now and hopefully it will be published in Natural Hazards Review sometime soon.

    Comment by kevin v — August 5, 2007 @

  7. @ paul:
    The impression is unintentional, and rectified.

    @ Darrel Jones:
    I tried the numbers both with only an ‘$’ in front and the ‘dollars’ behind, and either option looked like it lacked something. But I see your point.

    @ kevin v:
    Your credentials outrank Wikipedia, so I’ve adapted the figures on your authority!

    Comment by strangemaps — August 6, 2007 @

  8. [...] 161 - Map of the San Francisco Quake and Fire (1906) « strange maps (tags: y9_hazards y9_earthquakes) [...]

    Pingback by geography blogging alltheway » Blog Archiv » links for 2007-08-06 — August 6, 2007 @

  9. This all is really cool. You might want to check out Paula Scher’s typography maps. I have one on my blog. http://jessicatillyer.wordpress.com/

    Comment by jessicatillyer — August 6, 2007 @

  10. Even accounting for the fact this map was a drawing, what struck me was how it depicts a few key buildings and vast areas of grey nothingness. When I first saw it, it reminded me of nothing as much as the aerial photos of Hiroshima taken just after the 1945 bombing. Chilling.

    Comment by jay denari — August 16, 2007 @

  11. “500 presumed looters were shot” ??

    I thought we had presumption of innocence until proven guilty before 1906. Why just shoot them instead of arresting them?

    Comment by John M. — August 20, 2007 @

  12. My Aunt, Gertrude Mills, was a nurse at the time. But she lived in Palo Alto. She walked to San Francisco to help at one of the hospitals there. I often wonder how long it took and how she got over the rubble and through the wreckage. I also wonder how many people came from outlying towns, and from how far away, to help.

    Comment by Dale Milne — September 3, 2007 @

  13. Where did you find this map? H.M. Pettit was my father’s uncle. I’ve seen other maps by him but not this one. Thanks.

    Comment by BETH — September 20, 2007 @

  14. @ BETH:

    I’m pleased I could help you discover a map made by your relative!

    The map is located at the website of the William L. Clements Library at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor (http://www.clements.umich.edu/), more specifically in the Exhibits section.

    Comment by strangemaps — September 20, 2007 @

  15. This is a wonderful site.
    Thankyou very very much.

    Comment by redneckarts — October 17, 2007 @

  16. this is so lame i need the map of iran you know the map of calaforina april 20th 1906

    Comment by sid-sid — December 2, 2007 @

  17. my bad i need the map of san diego find it plese e-mail me at sss_super@hotmail.com today plezzzzzzzzzzzzz.

    Comment by sid-sid — December 2, 2007 @

  18. [...] замечательный! Weeks’ worth of browsing, including a simplified map of London, a map of SF 1906 quake, a map of the coming apocalypse and a lot more goodies. Кстати, тоже на WordPress-е, [...]

    Pingback by Radio LesTP » Blog Archive » Три карты, три карты, три карты — December 6, 2007 @

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.