Strange Maps

August 28, 2007

169 - The British Isles Inside Borneo

Filed under: Uncategorized — strangemaps @

map-1.jpg

Preceded only by faraway Greenland (2.130.800 sq. km, 822.706 sq. mi.) and nearby New Guinea (785.753 sq. km, 303.381 sq. mi.), Borneo is the third-largest island in the world (748.168 sq. km, 288.869 sq. mi.) That’s a somewhat surprising accolade for this low-key South East Asian island with an institutionally split personality.

Borneo is shared by three states: the southern chunk is Indonesian, most of the northern part is Malaysian except for the enclaved sovereign sultanate of Brunei Darussalam (itself consisting of two non-contiguous parts). The Indonesians refer to their part of the island as Kalimantan, in Malaysia the Bornean states of Sabah and Sarawak are simply referred to as East Malaysia.

The two main British Isles are a bit further down the list of largest islands. Great Britain (218.595 sq. km, 84.400 sq. mi.) still is the eighth-largest, after the Japanese main island of Honshu and before the Canadian arctic island of Victoria . Ireland (81.638 sq. km, 31.521 sq. mi.), i.e. the Republic plus Northern Ireland (the British-governed part of Ireland) is the world’s 20th-largest island, after the southern Philippine island of Mindanao and before the northern Japanese island of Hokkaido. Together, they measure up about 300.000 sq. km (116.000 sq. mi.), or less than half of Borneo.

For the benefit of his primarily British readers, 19th-century naturalist and explorer Alfred Russel Wallace included this map in his 1869 book The Malay Archipelago, comparing the size of the British Isles with that of Borneo to give them an idea of the vastness of the place. The British Isles are shown in their normal projection (north up) while Borneo is tilted (east up) to provide better shelter for the British Isles.

Welsh-born Alfred Russel Wallace (1823-1913) dedicated his book to “Charles Darwin, author of The Origin of Species (…) not only as a token of personal esteem and friendship, but also to express my deep admiration for his genius and works.”

Yet Wallace was quite an important figure himself in the field of evolutionary biology, as in anthropology and geographical exploration. While exploring the Malay archipelago, he discovered the Wallace line, dividing the Australian fauna from that of Asia. Also named after him are Wallace’s flying frog and the ‘Wallace effect’, the hypothesis that natural selection can contribute to the reproductive isolation of incipient species by encouraging varieties to develop barriers to hybridisation. Wallace proposed a theory of natural selection independent of Darwin, prompting the latter to publish his theory sooner than intended.

Although not the acknowledged progenitor of the evolution theory, Wallace is considered the father of biogeography, the study of the geographical distribution of animal species. In fact in biogeography, ‘Wallacea’ describes a group of Indonesian islands separated by deep water from Asia as well as Australia (i.e. Lombok, Komodo, Flores, Sumba, Timor, Sulawesi and the North Moluccan islands).

The Malay Archipelago was one of the most popular journals of scientific exploration of its time, kept continuously in print from its publication in 1869 into the second decade of the 20th century. Joseph Conrad (of Heart of Darkness fame) called it his “favourite bedside companion”. Despite his scientific importance, Wallace’s relations with other evolutionists were somewhat strained by his belief in spiritualism. He is sometimes labelled one of the ‘forgotten evolutionists’. Darwin successfully campaigned for Wallace to receive a state pension of £200 per annum so that he could overcome the endemic poverty he lived in at the time.

This map, placing Sarawak just off Ireland’s westernmost Dingle Peninsula, London on the Prime Meridian, slicing off Borneo’s south and the Shetlands touching Borneo’s eastern side, can be found here on papuaweb, a website dedicated to issues relevant to the Indonesian provinces of Papua and Papua Barat (formerly collectively known as Irian Jaya) for students, researchers, development workers, community leaders, government agencies and others.

27 Comments »

  1. Victoria isn’t an “Arctic” island, it’s off the coast of southern Britishb Columbia.

    Comment by puzzledcanadian — August 28, 2007 @

  2. Last time I looked Australia was an island..

    Comment by Picky — August 28, 2007 @

  3. Regarding the “formerly Irian Jaya” bit, I think not. Either I’m very much mistaken, or Irian Jaya included all of the indonesian part of New Guinea (and outlying islands), and it appears, from this page here, that it is now divided into two provinces, most of it becoming Papua and the westernmost peninsula becoming Irja Barat (which does resonate with Irian Jaya; sounds almost like an acronym).

    Got to thank you anyway: I wasn’t aware of this administrative change.

    Comment by Jorge — August 28, 2007 @

  4. @ puzzledcanadian:
    you refer to Victoria, the capital city of Vancouver Island. Victoria Island is Canada’s second-largest island, after Baffin Island. It’s in the Arctic, divided between Nunavut and the Northwest Territories.

    @ Picky:
    True, Australia is the smallest of continents and is sometimes dubbed the ‘Island Continent’, but at three times the size of Greenland, it’s counted as a continent by many if not most geographers.

    @ Jorge:
    You are right. The western, Indonesian-controlled part of the island of New Guinea, is now divided into two parts: provinsi Papua and provinsi Irja Barat. Wikipedia says the latter province was renamed Papua Barat (’West Papua’) in February of this year.

    Comment by strangemaps — August 28, 2007 @

  5. @jorge: Yes, Irja is an acronym for Irian Jaya. Although Indonesian does have acronyms and initialisms formed with single letters from each word, it’s more common to take syllables from each word and combine them.

    For example, Kalimantan Selatan (S. Kalimantan)> Kalsel,
    Jawa Timur(East Java)> Jatim, Sulawesi Utara (North Sulawesi)> Sulut, Sumatera Barat (West Sumatra) > Sumbar.

    Comment by bingley — August 29, 2007 @

  6. [...] Read it. More than you ever really wanted to know about Borneo. But the map is cool. [...]

    Pingback by DYSPEPSIA GENERATION » Blog Archive » The British Isles Inside Borneo — August 29, 2007 @

  7. The line shown on this map ia NOT the equator, it is the Prime Meridian, which passes thruogh Greenwich, which is a suburb of London, just to the SE of downtown London. The equator would cut through Borneo diagonally from lower left to upper right, due to the way Borneo is drawn w/ north to the upper left. The equator would split Borneo into almost equal halves.

    Comment by James Grose — August 29, 2007 @

  8. That’s a very neat fit! Well done, Wallace.

    Mod - you might want to correct the tag somewhere after the first Darwin reference. It’s influencing all the way to the comment section…

    Comment by Yuval — August 29, 2007 @

  9. @ James Grose:
    Ah, but of course. Very obvious, now that you mention it. Rectifying…

    @Yuval:
    Thanks, done!

    Comment by strangemaps — August 29, 2007 @

  10. The “British-governed northern part” of Ireland is actually “Northern Ireland”, not “Ulster”. Ulster is one the four historic provinces of Ireland, and is bigger than Northern Ireland, also including three counties that are part of the Republic of Ireland.

    Comment by Tony — August 29, 2007 @

  11. Nothing like geography to stir up some controversy.

    Comment by Brian — August 29, 2007 @

  12. Interesting article, and an engaging discussion after. It is fascinating how many people still enjoy geograhy.

    Thanks for the great post.

    ~JRA

    Comment by jrantonini — August 29, 2007 @

  13. @ Tony:
    Ulster has several meanings, one of which is the one you describe. Another equates ‘Ulster’ with ‘Northern Ireland’, but this term is used mainly by the Unionist community alone. I’ll follow your more precise definition.

    @Brian:
    Quite! :)

    Comment by strangemaps — August 29, 2007 @

  14. There was an interesting article in the NYT yesterday about historical biogeography, written by Carl Zimmer. It’s about related species of Mite Harvestmen (related to Daddy Longlegs) living very very far away from each other. Mite Harvestmen have very small ranges, yet closely related species are found all over the globe. The explanation is that these related species all populated different areas of Pangea, and traveled with the continents as they spread apart. Both the blog and the article have some cool maps describing this process.

    His blog post about it can be found here:
    http://scienceblogs.com/loom/2007/08/28/the_mystery_of_the_wandering_d.php

    And the article itself is here:
    http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/28/science/28daddy.html

    Comment by benjamin — August 29, 2007 @

  15. I always enjoy reading and looking at your maps. Especially the background stories are very interesting. I therefore thought I should tell you a map joke. Maybe you already know it?

    “Do you know why the euro will never become a hard currency in Sweden?” Look at a euro coin and you’ll understand.

    Comment by Gustaf Redemo — August 30, 2007 @

  16. The definition of an “Island” is interesting - I really don’t see why Australia is not included.

    Although, since all land is surrounded by water, one could call the Africa/Europe/Asia land mass an “island” too.

    Comment by Robert — August 30, 2007 @

  17. @Gustaf Redemo:
    I’m afraid the design of the euro coins have been changed (perhaps due to this joke).

    Old design:
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bd/2e_comm.png

    New design:
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a2/2_euro_coins.png

    Comment by Anders — August 30, 2007 @

  18. Like Gustaf, I enjoy reading your blog and looking at you maps… That’s why you’re one of the 5 blogs I’m linking to in this BlogDay :

    http://www.manteela.be/blog/index.php?2007/08/31/98-blogday-2007

    Comment by LapinLove404 — August 31, 2007 @

  19. @Anders: I did a quick look in my pocket and saw that all the coins I had were with the old design. I wonder how long it will take until the old ones are gone? Anyway thanks for pointing that out.

    Comment by Gustaf Redemo — August 31, 2007 @

  20. Actually, the Australian govt classifies Australia as both the world’s largest island and the world’s smallest continent.

    personally, any landmass that takes a week to drive across is no island

    Comment by Nudge — September 4, 2007 @

  21. If Australia’s an island, what isn’t? Might as well say all of Euroasia is an island as well. Isn’t the continent called Oceana, not Australia?

    Comment by Scott — October 9, 2007 @

  22. The title of the entry is of course factually incorrect.

    I have never met anyone from the Republic of Ireland who would refer to these islands as “The British Isles”. I suggest “The British Isles and Ireland”.

    Is there any way you could make a correction? The wording of this page does not represent the view of some 4.5m people in the Republic of Ireland.

    Comment by Seán — October 19, 2007 @

  23. @ Benjamin:
    Thanks - very interesting article, and blog.

    @ Gustaf Redemo & Anders:
    Cool, I’d heard about this, but never seen the two designs next to each other.

    @ LapinLove404:
    Although somewhat late: Merci beaucoup nonetheless!

    @ Nudge:
    I like your definition. Will remember it for when it comes up in conversation. (Which outside the rarefied environs of map-blogs like these probably is ‘never’).

    @ Séan:
    There’s a difference between the political and geographical definition of ‘British’. But one definition influences the other, to the effect that most people in the Irish Republic would never accept being labelled ‘British’, not even in a geographical sense. And yet, in at least one definition of that sense, the British Isles include *all* the islands off Europe’s north-west coast (from the Channel Islands upto and including the Shetlands). Politicians (and others) often sidestep the issue by referring to Ireland and Great Britain simply as ‘these islands’.

    Comment by strangemaps — October 19, 2007 @

  24. Where’s Madagascar? I always thought that was the second largest island after Greenland. (not counting Australia)

    Comment by Rob Leemhuis — October 30, 2007 @

  25. Please stop using the term “British Isles” It is long outdated. Ireland is not British.

    Comment by Seamus — January 8, 2008 @

  26. [...] knew that Papau New Guinea is such a polyglot society that it dwarfs the rest of the world? Or that Great Britain could easily fit within Borneo? If you think this sounds all a bit too heavy, there are maps of the US made out of pumpkins, [...]

    Pingback by fourth edition » Mapping the World — February 6, 2008 @

  27. The Irish government and the EU are opposed to the term “British Isles” and discourage its usage.
    The term “British Isles” in a geographical sense was coined by the British after colonisation of the “Irish Isles”. It was never acceptable to Irish people and it is about time British people realsied that. The correct term is “The British and Irish Isles” when refering to these islands.

    Comment by Ciara — July 12, 2008 @

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.