Strange Maps

September 6, 2007

173 - The Hungry Gulf Crocodile

Filed under: Uncategorized — strangemaps @

persiangulfgator1.jpg

When historians look back on the current conflict in Iraq, they might very well call it the Third Gulf War. The first one would have been the Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988), considered by many to be the longest conventional war of the 20th century. The second one, then, would be the reconquest of Kuwait by the US and its allies following Kuwait’s invasion and annexation by Iraq (1990-1991). The third one, started in 2003 by the US-led invasion of Iraq proper, is still ongoing.

Some commentators, however, only refer to the second conflict as the First Gulf War, making the present one the Second. Naming stuff is an explosive subject in the Gulf region. In fact, whether it should be called the Persian Gulf, the Arabian Gulf or the Arabo-Persian Gulf is a hotly contested matter, leading most commentators to refer to it simply as ‘the Gulf’.

This cartoon map, nicely morphing the shape of the Gulf into the threatening mouth of a crocodile, is the work of John Wagner, who sent it to me, explaining that it was “created for a newspaper story regarding the perils of US intervention in the Persian Gulf before the First Persian Gulf War. The story, and hence, the art exhibit considerable prescience in the light of current events, although the scope of those under threat in the years since includes many, many others besides a US missile frigate and an oil tanker.”

Because of the confusion explained here, I’m not sure whether Mr Wagner refers to the (1980-1988) or the (1990-1991) conflict. In any case, the cartoon nicely depicts the dangers of navigating and policing a body of water that at the same time was and remains crucial for oil transports and had been mined, and could have been closed off quite easily by blocking the Strait of Hormuz.

18 Comments »

  1. Actually, I believe Mr. Wagner is referring to the events of Operation Earnest Will (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Earnest_Will), the tanker reflagging and escorting effort that occurred during the Reagan Administration.

    This was connected in some ways to the Iran-Iraq War (as I generally think of it) and had little to do with either Gulf War One (1990-1991) or Two (2003-present).

    Comment by David Hecht — September 6, 2007 @

  2. I have never heard of the Iran-Iraq War called the First Gulf War before you did so, while the Kuwait/1991 one is very commonly called that. So I find your confusion hard to believe here.

    Comment by Nomenclature — September 6, 2007 @

  3. The geography involved really shows why our dependance on foreign oil, and oil in general, is a bad idea. A more serious attempt to mine and blockade the gulf than by Iran in the 1980’s would easily cut that lifeline.

    The gulf blockade that happened then wasn’t implemented as throuroughly as it could have been due to Iran’s naval inferiority compared to the US. So all they could do was occasional fast attack boats, air launched anti-shipping missiles, and mines that were launched in Iranian waters and left to drift towards the Straits of Hormuz.

    Comment by David Schwartz — September 6, 2007 @

  4. Is it just me, or are some of teeth on the coast of Iran shaped like missiles?

    Comment by AllenStibble — September 6, 2007 @

  5. And I thought the Arabian Gulf was an arm of the Red Sea…

    Comment by James — September 6, 2007 @

  6. What a map! The perils of intervention in the Persian Gulf and wider Middle East have always been great, but so are the payoffs. Despite what Mr. Schwartz points out, long-term dependence on foreign oil appears to be a “fact-on-the-ground.” Not even totally ending our dependence on oil for energy would end the world’s dependence on foreign oil for rubber and plastics, asphalt for highway construction, and so forth.

    According to most research by strategic experts, the ‘choke points’ of global container ship and oil shipping are actually fairly open. Because of the presence of both CENTCOM (in Qatar) and Joint Task Force Horn of Africa, the future Africa Command, in Djibouti and friendly governments in the Gulf States. Iran is highly integrated into the global oil economy and dependent on oil and gas shipments to support the economy and probably would avoid shutting down oil shipments even in the event of a regional war.

    A greater danger would be the Suez Canal, if Egypt ever fell to radicals. Ideological governments often don’t perceive the long-term negative consequences of short term militancy.

    Sorry for the long post!

    Comment by LessThanExpert — September 7, 2007 @

  7. He’s talking about the “Tanker War,” I believe, which involved the reflagging of oil tankers and the protection thereof by the U.S. Navy in the waning years of the Iran-Iraq War.

    Comment by TigerHawk — September 7, 2007 @

  8. Has anyone else noticed Bahrain’s missing? It should be in the Gulf.

    Comment by Darrel Jones — September 7, 2007 @

  9. Odd thought… the Persian Gulf is a lot like the Baltic Sea. Russia is the equivalent of Iraq (a big nation whose sea access is through a constricted channel bounded by potentially hostile nations) Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia are Kuwait, Denmark is UAE, Germany is Saudi Arabia, and Sweden is Iran. The politics of the Baltic may be peaceful now, but its history of conflicts has a lot in common with the history of the Persian Gulf: the shape of continents really does shape history.

    Comment by Christof Spieler — September 7, 2007 @

  10. Shouldn’t that read “the liberation of Kuwait by the US and its allies”, since the US didn’t keep the territory.

    Comment by chad — September 7, 2007 @

  11. I was thinking something along the lines of what Chad mentioned. Either way, a very cool, very accurate map!

    Comment by Brian — September 7, 2007 @

  12. The reason for some of the crocodile teeth along the Iranian shore, are depicted as missiles, is a reference to the Silkworm missiles that Iran has deployed, and threatened to use during the 1980-88 Iran/Iraq war.

    Comment by James Grose — September 7, 2007 @

  13. [...] 173 - The Hungry Gulf Crocodile « strange maps : [...]

    Pingback by Present Tensed » Interesting Links/Articles between September 6th and September 8th — September 9, 2007 @

  14. Going through the archives, I noticed that today marks the one-year anniversary for your wonderful blog! Congratulations, and thank you for all the interesting and funny maps you have brought to our attention so far - and here’s to many more!

    Comment by Espen B — September 10, 2007 @

  15. re: “I have never heard of the Iran-Iraq War called the First Gulf War before you did so… I find your confusion hard to believe here”

    The BBC called it ‘The Gulf War’ right through its coverage during the 1980s. Bulloch and Morris’s 1989 book was entitled ‘The Gulf War: Its Origins, History, and Consequences’.

    The difference in nomenclature in the US is understandable: only wars in which they fight get to be numbered.

    Comment by pseudonymous in nc — September 10, 2007 @

  16. Of course, if the crocodile snapped its teeth together, it would shut off its source of sustenance. I suppose there are some who would consider this a good thing. Merkins messing with a crocodile is surely rampant provocation.

    Comment by lordhutton — September 10, 2007 @

  17. [...] They shift perspective. You leave them with a sense not only of place, but of meaning.Take the Hungry Gulf Crocodile, seen above. More than just being a map, it tells you somthing fundamental about that place. The [...]

    Pingback by topical maps « free association — September 11, 2007 @

  18. [...] maps, maps as political cartoons, and an interesting map comparing the world’s GDP to our fifty states. It is interesting just [...]

    Pingback by Principled Discovery » Saying it with cartography — November 12, 2007 @

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.