Strange Maps

February 5, 2008

240 - The American Eagle, About to Spread Its Wings

Filed under: Uncategorized — strangemaps @

17263.jpg

In 1833, The United States didn’t have an East Coast yet, for lack of a West Coast. The gigantic Louisiana Territory, acquired some 30 years earlier from the French, gave America dominion over the Mississippi basin, but Mexican land and the Oregon territory, claimed by Great Britain, still stood between the US and its ‘Manifest Destiny‘ – to stretch “from sea to shining sea”.

That’s a line from Katharine Lee Bates’ song ‘America the Beautiful‘, composed in 1893 when the west was won, mainly by the Mexican-American War of 1846-’48. It would be many decades before all the lands between Mississippi and Pacific would enter the Union as full-fledged states, but the iconic shape of America’s lower 48 states was there.

In 1833, other icons were still vying for public acknowledgement. For example, this Eagle Map of the United States, Engraved For Rudiments of National Knowledge.

The map represents America as an eagle (it looks more like a dove), with its head coinciding with New England (except Maine), its eye with Vermont, its neckline following Lakes Ontario and Erie, the wing outlines Lakes Huron and Superior (and further west the eventual Canadian-American border at the 49th parallel).

The eagle’s breast follows the Atlantic seaboard, its talons form Florida – even though the claws protrude far from the coastline, and somewhat ominously, towards Cuba.

The real reason why this particular iconic representation of America’s national bird never caught on, is in the tailfeathers – shaped to follow a border no longer in existence by 1848. The western borders of the subsequent independent and later US state of Texas are recognisable, for now as the dividing line between the US and Mexico. The feathers follow the US inland border as it moves north, and disappears out of sight at the area disputed with Great Britain.

Meanwhile, the great inland empire of Louisiana is already being divided up into US states, with Louisiana and Missouri separated from the ‘mainland’ of the formerly French lands.

This map was published in Philadelphia in 1833 by Carey & Hart, in a now extremely rare atlas, the Rudiments of National Knowledge, Presented To The Youth of the United States, And To Enquiring Foreigners, By A Citizen Of Pennsylvania.

An image of this map was sent in by antique maps dealer Barry Ruderman, who recently put an original copy of the map up for sale. It’s yours for just under 20,000 dollars, indicating just how rare it is. “This is the first example of the map we have seen on the market in the past 10 years,” states the relevant page at Ruderman’s website www.raremaps.com - not in any way affiliated with Strange Maps, I hasten to add. It just so happens that in this case, the rare map also is a strange one.

29 Comments »

  1. Poor Maine got left out :(

    Comment by Matthew Gallant — February 6, 2008 @

  2. I wonder what other images are in that atlas. Also, that title is great. I wonder what the ration of Pennsylvania to Federal was in it?

    Comment by Lurker — February 6, 2008 @

  3. If the eagle were to turn his head completely around and look up, he could get Maine in there. And raptors can do that.

    Comment by Rey Fox — February 6, 2008 @

  4. reminds me of

    http://www.animalsontheunderground.com/the_animals.html

    which I’m sure has been mentioned here before

    Comment by nergalicious — February 6, 2008 @

  5. Looks more like a pigeon to me. That could have been embarrassing…

    Comment by kingrollo — February 6, 2008 @

  6. “..head coinciding with New England (except Maine)”

    always felt Maine would be more at home in Canada.

    Comment by neil c — February 6, 2008 @

  7. Thank you for the post! Interesting that the Eagle was chosen when Hawks were far more prevalent on the East Coast at the time and the West was just a dream.

    Comment by courtney benson — February 6, 2008 @

  8. “..head coinciding with New England (except Maine)”

    always felt Maine would be more at home in Canada.

    Comment by neil c — February 6, 2008 @

    Actually Vermont would feel more home as part of Canada– what with their Socialist senator, Bernie Sanders and their “Ben and Jerry’s”, etc. They’re not as Socialist in Maine as they are in Vermont….

    Comment by Shawn Fahrer — February 6, 2008 @

  9. Stupid question: Why are the 48 contiguous states called the “lower” states? Hippopotomonstrosesquipedaliophobia?

    Comment by Jann — February 6, 2008 @

  10. Because Alaska is “upper,” Jann; and yes, Hawaii, which is “lower” than any other state, is left out of the formulation.

    Comment by Huntington — February 6, 2008 @

  11. Definitely looks more like a “dove of peace” to me - not a ravenous raptor. I think the rounded head and thick neck are the problem. If they wanted to make the eagle look more ominous, they should have annexed New Jersey back to England.

    Comment by badflags — February 6, 2008 @

  12. Looks more like a pigeon than an eagle from where I stand.

    “The flying rat”… yeah it works too.

    Comment by Bazza — February 6, 2008 @

  13. The old U.S. isn’t the only country that resembles an Eagle… Azerbaijan today still uses a superimposed eagle on their map to imply… something.

    Here’s Azerbaijan…

    http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/NaturalHazards/Archive/May2003/azerbaijan.TMO05may2003_lrg.jpg

    You can sort of see where the Eagle fits… I just can’t find the superimposed version (that seems to be on the front cover of every Azeri menu) on google… Anyone else?

    Comment by TJ — February 7, 2008 @

  14. Slight error in your text: “The western borders of the subsequent independent and later US state of Texas are recognisable,” I believe the *eastern* borders are meant.

    And, is it just me, or is Indiana’s western border slightly off? I didn’t htink the point where it meets the southern part of Lake Michigan was so far west, looks like it should be kicked east a few miles or so.

    Comment by David — February 7, 2008 @

  15. cool map!!! any maps in asia to share

    http://www.xanga.com/idot60
    http://allthewaytothetop.blogspot.com

    Comment by ping — February 7, 2008 @

  16. Looks rather inexpertly drawn, considering it went to press. The Michigan/Indiana/Ohio junction is a smooth parallel, while Illinois is just a smudge to the East than in this representation…and other little details that could have been corrected.

    However, those errancies likely add to the value instead of detract from it. Note also the most liberal instance of Virginia–seeing as how this was a pre-Civil War map, the Appalachian rump hadn’t yet broken off. I wonder how much different things would be today if Virginia’s territorial integrity had not been compromised?

    Comment by The Dutchman! — February 7, 2008 @

  17. Incidentally I have seen this map before, if you download Google Earth this map is one of the available layers. It is found at Layers/Primary Database/Gallery/Rumsey Historical Maps/United States 1833

    Comment by Brett Dunbar — February 7, 2008 @

  18. “..head coinciding with New England (except Maine)”

    always felt Maine would be more at home in Canada.”
    ————————

    We Mainers are quite happy to be Americans, thanks. Maine had only been a state for 13 years at the time this map was printed, so I think we can forgive the slight oversight. Besides, the eastern border doesn’t appear to be border we have today.

    Comment by cknason — February 7, 2008 @

  19. Very nice!

    Comment by michael5000 — February 7, 2008 @

  20. @16

    At the time of this map, the Michigan/Ohio border was under dispute, so the artist could be trying to illustrate that.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toledo_War

    Still, it seems a little too far south on this map.

    Even today, the Michigan/Indiana/Ohio border isn’t a smooth parallel; The Michigan/Ohio border is slightly further south.

    Comment by Boznia — February 7, 2008 @

  21. If this were a cardinal, Maine would perfectly fit its forehead

    Being from Maine, sometimes I wish we were Canada. Like being part of Atlantic Time. And Canadian are nicer people

    Comment by Art — February 7, 2008 @

  22. I love the phrase “Enquiring Foreigners”

    Comment by Tom Veil — February 7, 2008 @

  23. The Eastern Maine border was settled after this map was in print…there was a dispute about it, since the treaty delineating the border stated that it was to “the headwaters” of the river.

    Unfortunately, the river separating East Maine from New Brunswick has three tributaries which more-or-less meet up to form it. The American settlers thought that the true headwaters were the most Eastern tributary, while the Acadian settlers were apt to believe it was the most Western. Instead of compromising and splitting it along the centre (which was roughly equidistant), it nearly caused another war and when it went to arbitration the Eastern headwaters were selected.

    A similar dispute happened over the Alaskan panhandle, also in the Yanks’ favor. That one still stings some in BC to this day.

    Comment by The Dutchman! — February 8, 2008 @

  24. great map!
    thanks!

    Comment by mat geoportail — February 8, 2008 @

  25. South Carolina looks rather strange at its western end.

    Comment by Lurker — February 8, 2008 @

  26. They have a very high resolution copy of this map at the Library of Congress’s American Memory site, here: http://lcweb2.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/r?ammem/gmd:@filreq(@field(NUMBER%2B@band(g3700%2Bnp000151))%2B@field(COLLID%2Bnpmap))%20

    Comment by Jon S — February 17, 2008 @

  27. Great concept…

    Comment by trainerblog — March 1, 2008 @

  28. Is it just me, or does it look like a pigeon?

    Comment by Rissa — March 5, 2008 @

  29. [...] Eagle Map of the United States, from [...]

    Pingback by Strange Maps | The Computer Vet Weblog — March 25, 2008 @

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.